show that there is no positive n for which square root of n minus 1 end root +square root of n plus 1 end root  is rational
 

Asked by manavmansvi | 27th Jun, 2015, 06:40: PM

Expert Answer:

A s s u m e space t h a t space square root of n minus 1 end root plus square root of n plus 1 end root i s space r a t i o n a l. rightwards double arrow square root of n minus 1 end root plus square root of n plus 1 end root equals p over q comma space w h e r e space p space a n d space q space a r e space i n t e g e r s comma space q not equal to 0... left parenthesis 1 right parenthesis rightwards double arrow fraction numerator 1 over denominator square root of n minus 1 end root plus square root of n plus 1 end root end fraction equals q over p rightwards double arrow fraction numerator 1 over denominator square root of n minus 1 end root plus square root of n plus 1 end root end fraction cross times fraction numerator square root of n minus 1 end root minus square root of n plus 1 end root over denominator square root of n minus 1 end root minus square root of n plus 1 end root end fraction equals q over p rightwards double arrow fraction numerator square root of n minus 1 end root minus square root of n plus 1 end root over denominator n minus 1 minus open parentheses n plus 1 close parentheses end fraction equals q over p rightwards double arrow fraction numerator square root of n minus 1 end root minus square root of n plus 1 end root over denominator n minus 1 minus n minus 1 end fraction equals q over p rightwards double arrow fraction numerator square root of n minus 1 end root minus square root of n plus 1 end root over denominator negative 2 end fraction equals q over p rightwards double arrow fraction numerator square root of n plus 1 end root minus square root of n minus 1 end root over denominator 2 end fraction equals q over p rightwards double arrow square root of n plus 1 end root minus square root of n minus 1 end root equals fraction numerator 2 q over denominator p end fraction... left parenthesis 2 right parenthesis A d d i n g space e q u a t i o n s space left parenthesis 1 right parenthesis space a n d space left parenthesis 2 right parenthesis comma space open parentheses square root of n minus 1 end root plus square root of n plus 1 end root close parentheses plus open parentheses square root of n plus 1 end root minus square root of n minus 1 end root close parentheses equals p over q plus fraction numerator 2 q over denominator p end fraction rightwards double arrow open parentheses square root of n minus 1 end root plus square root of n plus 1 end root close parentheses plus open parentheses square root of n plus 1 end root minus square root of n minus 1 end root close parentheses equals fraction numerator p squared plus 2 q squared over denominator p q end fraction rightwards double arrow 2 square root of n plus 1 end root equals fraction numerator p squared plus 2 q squared over denominator p q end fraction rightwards double arrow square root of n plus 1 end root equals fraction numerator p squared plus 2 q squared over denominator 2 p q end fraction rightwards double arrow n plus 1 equals open square brackets fraction numerator p squared plus 2 q squared over denominator 2 p q end fraction close square brackets squared... left parenthesis 3 right parenthesis S u b t r a c t i n g space e q u a t i o n s space left parenthesis 2 right parenthesis space f r o m space left parenthesis 1 right parenthesis comma space w e space h a v e comma space open parentheses square root of n minus 1 end root plus square root of n plus 1 end root close parentheses minus open parentheses square root of n plus 1 end root minus square root of n minus 1 end root close parentheses equals p over q minus fraction numerator 2 q over denominator p end fraction rightwards double arrow open parentheses square root of n minus 1 end root plus square root of n plus 1 end root close parentheses minus open parentheses square root of n plus 1 end root minus square root of n minus 1 end root close parentheses equals fraction numerator p squared minus 2 q squared over denominator p q end fraction rightwards double arrow 2 square root of n minus 1 end root equals fraction numerator p squared minus 2 q squared over denominator p q end fraction rightwards double arrow square root of n minus 1 end root equals fraction numerator p squared minus 2 q squared over denominator 2 p q end fraction rightwards double arrow n minus 1 equals open square brackets fraction numerator p squared minus 2 q squared over denominator 2 p q end fraction close square brackets squared... left parenthesis 4 right parenthesis A d d i n g space e q u a t i o n s space left parenthesis 3 right parenthesis space a n d space left parenthesis 4 right parenthesis comma space w e space h a v e comma n plus 1 plus n minus 1 equals open square brackets fraction numerator p squared plus 2 q squared over denominator 2 p q end fraction close square brackets squared minus open square brackets fraction numerator p squared minus 2 q squared over denominator 2 p q end fraction close square brackets squared rightwards double arrow n plus 1 plus n minus 1 equals 2... left parenthesis 5 right parenthesis F r o m space e q u a t i o n s space left parenthesis 3 right parenthesis space a n d space left parenthesis 4 right parenthesis comma space i t space i s space c l e a r space t h a t space n plus 1 space a n d space n minus 1 space a r e space p e r f e c t space s q u a r e s. B u t space a n y space t w o space p e r f e c t space s q u a r e s space d i f f e r space b y space a t l e a s t space 3. T h u s comma space o u r space a s s u m p t i o n space t h a t space square root of n minus 1 end root plus square root of n plus 1 end root i s space r a t i o n a l space i s space i n c o r r e c t. H e n c e comma space t h e r e space i s space n o space p o s i t i v e space apostrophe n apostrophe space s u c h space t h a t space square root of n minus 1 end root plus square root of n plus 1 end root i s space r a t i o n a l.

Answered by Vimala Ramamurthy | 28th Jun, 2015, 12:29: PM

Related Videos

This video explains the identification of series which is mathematically kn...

This video explains the identification of series, mathematically known as A...

Identification of series, mathematically known as Arithmetic Progression an...

All Questions Ask Doubt