why chlorine is an ortho para directing in electrophilic substitution despite being an electron withdrawing group
Asked by shreesh Kulkarni
| 7th Nov, 2013,
09:38: PM
This can be shown by two ways:
1. Reactivity towards an electrophile
The reactivity towards an electrophile depends upon the electron density on the benzene ring. If the electron density increases, electrophile attacks easily. As Cl withdraws electrons through inductive effect (-I effect), it tends to destabilize the intermediate carbocation towards electrophilic substitution.

2. Directive influence
Although Cl benzene is less reactive towards electrophilic aromatic substitution but if electrophile attacks and the product is to be formed, then it will be at o- and p- positions. This is because through resonance halogen tends to stabilize the carbocation and the effect is more pronounced at o- and p- positions.

This can be shown by two ways:
1. Reactivity towards an electrophile
The reactivity towards an electrophile depends upon the electron density on the benzene ring. If the electron density increases, electrophile attacks easily. As Cl withdraws electrons through inductive effect (-I effect), it tends to destabilize the intermediate carbocation towards electrophilic substitution.
2. Directive influence
Although Cl benzene is less reactive towards electrophilic aromatic substitution but if electrophile attacks and the product is to be formed, then it will be at o- and p- positions. This is because through resonance halogen tends to stabilize the carbocation and the effect is more pronounced at o- and p- positions.
Answered by Hanisha Vyas
| 11th Nov, 2013,
12:22: PM
Kindly Sign up for a personalised experience
- Ask Study Doubts
- Sample Papers
- Past Year Papers
- Textbook Solutions
Sign Up
Verify mobile number
Enter the OTP sent to your number
Change